Welcome to Jersey Mike's Newcastle
Located in the heart of Newcastle, Jersey Mike's offers a delightful experience for sandwich lovers. With a commitment to fresh ingredients and authentic flavors, this deli specializes in both hot and cold subs, including standout options like the #16 Mike's Chicken Philly and the #13 Original Italian, served “Mike's Way.” The welcoming atmosphere, complemented by friendly service, ensures a pleasant dining experience. Customers rave about the quality of the sandwiches and the delicious, freshly baked cookies. At Jersey Mike's Newcastle, every meal is a celebration of taste, making it a must-visit spot for anyone craving a satisfying sub!
-
6920 Coal Creek Pkwy SE #7, Newcastle, WA 98059 Hotline: (425) 449-8328
Welcome to Jersey Mike's Newcastle, where the delightful aroma of freshly sliced meats and cheeses greets you as soon as you step through the door. Located at 6920 Coal Creek Pkwy SE #7, Newcastle, WA 98059, this beloved deli has quickly become a go-to destination for sandwich enthusiasts in the area. From the first bite of a handcrafted sub, it’s clear that the quality of ingredients and the care taken in preparation set Jersey Mike’s apart from the crowd.
At Jersey Mike's, the focus is on authentic, flavorful subs. Their extensive menu includes both hot and cold subs that cater to a variety of tastes. Indulge in the signature #13 The Original Italian for a savory combination of provolone, ham, and salami, or heat things up with the #31 California Chicken Cheese Steak, generously stuffed with grilled chicken, lettuce, and mayo, all deliciously layered beneath white American cheese. If you're in need of some spice in your life, the #44 Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak boasts Frank's Red Hot Sauce and blue cheese dressing that adds a creamy kick to the classic flavor profile.
- Customer Favorites:
- #31 California Chicken Cheese Steak - $14.65
- #44 Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak - $15.25
- #13 The Original Italian - $14.65
- #55 Big Kahuna Chicken Cheese Steak - $15.25
The experience at Jersey Mike's Newcastle is enhanced by their friendly and welcoming staff, consistently noted for their positive attitude and attention to detail. As one customer, Paul F., aptly put it, this location deserves a "High 5" for their superb service. You can expect your order to be made just the way you like it, and if there’s ever an issue, the staff are quick to communicate and resolve it, as Steve F. discovered during his recent visit.
For those who love a little something sweet alongside their hearty meal, let’s not overlook the fresh-baked cookies—perfect for rounding off your sandwich experience. Sandra N. raves about the chocolate chip cookies, especially when they’re warmed up, providing the perfect finish to your meal.
Jersey Mike's Newcastle clearly excels in offering a quality sandwich experience, even if some diners express that prices lean a bit on the higher side. However, many customers, including Henry K. and Laura F., affirm that the taste and authenticity of the subs justify the cost, making them an effortless choice when craving a delicious sandwich.
In conclusion, Jersey Mike's Newcastle stands out not only for its delectable subs but also for its commitment to providing excellent service. Whether you're a local or just passing through Newcastle, make sure to stop in and sample one of their signature sandwiches—you won't be disappointed!
The giant sandwich is 13" and the normal size is 7". $25 for a 13" sandwich is a stretch. The taste is still there and delicious sandwich. $25 for one giant 13" sandwich is a bit much these days. One inch more than a $15 12in subway is not that giant. I would buy again if they had a promo.
I love this Jersey Mikes. Employees are always nice and they never get my order wrong. I 100% recommend!
Decent sandwich place in Newcastle, WA. Was visiting my mom and stepped out to grab a bite. The oil and vinegar dressing was poured on with flair but it was a tad too much quantity. Otherwise it's a good option if you're craving a sandwich in this hood.
Jersey Mike's Newcastle location on Coal Creek Pkwy. deserves a High 5! The service is always VG. The staff members are friendly and welcoming. The sandwiches are are also top notch! The best among the sandwich chains. When it comes to authentic sub sandwiches, they can't be beat. Try the #13 Original Italian on white, "Mike's Way" and your getting as genuine a sub sandwich as you'll find anywhere. I'm typically a "support the independent, local business" type guy but, the product doesn't lie! There are many good, in fact great independent sandwich shops in the Seattle and suburban vicinity. Jersey Mike's, done right, as at the Coal Creek location is as good as any of them.
this is actually the best place ever, their hot subs are amazing. I love the cheese steak phillys. also all the dudes working here are EXTREMELY nice and always making subs with a great attitude and friendly smile. my only bad encounter was with this lady who was overtly bossy (sorry not in the good girl boss way) but every else we've encountered is fantastic. the chocolate chip cookies here are GREAT. they'll even heat it up for you if you ask
There's only 1 american sandwich I like in this world (literally, I only like banh mi otherwise), and Jersey Mikes version is good! #13 with mayo, and trust me, you have to get their mayo (even though it's high macro) because so far nothing is as tasty. I don't even like mayo but for some reason in this sammie, it's so good. Their reward system is almost too good, so sign-up. I come here a few times a year when I need a sammie (& Meconi's is so far)!
First time customer of Jersey Mike's, having a BOGO coupon. The phone app made ordering easy and it was great that they offer curbside pick up. As I was getting into the car to drive to the store, I got a call from them, informing me they were out of the bread we had chosen. She asked whether I'd like to substitute another bread type or cancel the order - very good customer service! Pick up was very prompt and easy too. As for the food, our sammies were both good. Wifey had the portobello mushroom sub and I had the Big Kahuna cheesesteak sub. Both were very good although I was missing the heat from jalapeños in my sandwich. Were they missing or just super mild? An unsolved mystery. I thought their regular prices were on the high side compared to the big Sub way down the road but quality was good.